It seems that COVID-19 is almost over, and things are getting back to normal or the so called “new normal.” At least that is what Governor Cuomo led us to believe by issuing Executive Order No. 210 “Expiration of Executive Orders 202 and 205” on June 25, 2021. However, there is still a lot of confusion and controversy around the underlying repercussions of lifting the “tolling” of the statutes of limitation in New York, through Executive Order No. 202.72 on November 3, 2020. Questions have been raised around whether Governor Cuomo had the authority to “toll” the statutes of limitation and whether the “toll” is real or just merely a suspension. Not only was there confusion as to the Governor’s authority to take such action but which Executive Order applied to which statute.
The statutes of limitations, in short, is the prescriptive period established by law that a person has, following the events that gave rise to a claim, to start and file a case in a timely manner authorized by law. You may be wondering what the difference is between “tolling” or suspending the statutes of limitations. “Tolling” the statutes of limitations means that said prescriptive period stopped or “froze” when the relevant Execute Order was issued and the prescriptive period resumed once the “toll” was lifted. In other words, time stood still while everyone was dealing with the COVID-19 pandemic emergency. On the other hand, merely suspending the statutes of limitation would mean that all potential claims or filing deadlines that would have expired during the effective period of the relevant Executive Order, must have had to be filed the day following the expiration of the suspension order.
Cases have now reached the courts and, so far, the Courts seem to agree that Governor Cuomo had the statutory authority to “toll” the statutes of limitation pursuant to Executive Law § 29-a(2)(d). The courts’ decisions also lean towards a commonsense approach since it would be impractical and unrealistic to only suspend the limitation periods and deadlines, given the high caseload and backlog the courts currently have, consequently creating or exacerbating systemic chaos. However, this topic should be of interest to everyone as more cases flood the New York courthouses to clarify or explain the applicability of the Governor’s tolling orders and his subsequent lifting of such orders.